Dissecting Deron Williams

I’m not an NBA player. Not even close. In fact, the player I would resemble the most is one Muggsy Bogues. And even I’m a little bit taller than the 5 foot 3 inches that he was. So far be it from me to criticise an NBA player. An NBA superstar no less. But yet I feel I have to as I can hold it in no longer, so here it goes. Is Deron Williams really that good?

Take a breath before you search for my contact details and give me a mouthful, and hear me out. I like Deron Williams, and I really admire his play. Williams is good, great even, and people talk about him as one of the best point guards in the league, if not the best. But for me, I don’t think he’s a top 5 point guard in the NBA, and I’ll tell you why. Firstly, I believe that both Chris Paul and a healthy Derrick Rose are better players, no question. They influence the game more, and more importantly they make those around them better. I’m not saying Williams doesn’t do these things, just the other two do it better. When you think of Chris Paul and Derrick Rose, you think of that unbelievable desire to win that they both possess. Close your eyes and imagine both Paul and Rose winning and NBA title. Can you do it? I know I can. Now try and do the same with Deron Williams. Well, how’d you do?

Rajon Rondo is the most unorthodox point guard in the league, and his style of play never ceases to amaze. For years people spoke about the ‘Big 3’ and rightly so, but it was Rondo who made them tick with his unrivalled passing ability. Add a title to his resume, even though he was drafted into a good situation, and he has to go above Williams.

So as of right now Williams sits at fourth best point guard in the league, and this is where the argument gets a little tricky. Russell Westbrook is not everybody’s cup of tea, and I get that. He is an erratic shooter and there are facets of his game which need work. But he is only 23 years old, and already has more playoff experience than Williams, including that all important trip to the Finals last year. He has also shown he has that big game mentality. Now Williams was part of some very good Utah Jazz teams, with one of the best coaches the NBA has ever had in Jerry Sloan, yet he never reached the Finals there. Of course some great teams stood in their way back then, most notably the San Antonin Spurs who beat them four games to one in the Western Conference Finals in 2007. So now Williams sits at fifth. (Kind of.)

Things really do become hazy now. Steve Nash, despite being ancient, has more individual honours than Deron, as well as now playing for a title contender in the Lakers, so does that make him the better player? The better choice to have at point guard for your team? He certainly knows how to run an offense in a way no other player does. He has also been a league MVP twice, while Williams has never even made the All-NBA first team. Or maybe you go with the massive potential and upswing of Kyrie Irving at this point? A little premature sure, but in his one season in the league he has already turned heads and made the worst team of 2010, the Cleveland Cavaliers, look respectable once more. If Kyrie was in Deron’s position, think of how good he could make the Brooklyn Nets in the long run. Some may argue this Nets team isn’t built for the long run, but who wouldn’t want long term stability and definite All-Star ability at the point guard position for at least a decade? Similarly, if Williams played for the Cavaliers, would they be a better team? Probably yes, although Williams didn’t exactly set the basketball world ablaze while playing for a poor New Jersey Nets team. So there is competition even for that number five spot I have so cruelly bestowed upon him.

Deron Williams could prove me wrong next year, and I hope he does. Now really is his chance. On paper, this is the best team he will ever have run the point on. Perhaps not as deep as the Utah teams he once graced, but certainly with far more star-power. By next summer he could be hoisting the Larry O’Brien trophy high into the air, whilst also clutching his first NBA Finals MVP award. That would certainly shut me up, but I just can’t see the Barclays Center hanging a banner from the rafters quite yet.

I’m not an NBA player. Not even close. In fact, the player I would resemble the most is one Muggsy Bogues. And even I’m a little bit taller than the 5 foot 3 inches that he was. So far be it from me to criticise an NBA player. An NBA superstar no less. But yet I feel I have to as I can hold it in no longer, so here it goes. Is Deron Williams really that good?

Take a breath before you search for my contact details and give me a mouthful, and hear me out. I like Deron Williams, and I really admire his play. Williams is good, great even, and people talk about him as one of the best point guards in the league, if not the best. But for me, I don’t think he’s a top 5 point guard in the NBA, and I’ll tell you why. Firstly, I believe that both Chris Paul and a healthy Derrick Rose are better players, no question. They influence the game more, and more importantly they make those around them better. I’m not saying Williams doesn’t do these things, just the other two do it better. When you think of Chris Paul and Derrick Rose, you think of that unbelievable desire to win that they both possess. Close your eyes and imagine both Paul and Rose winning and NBA title. Can you do it? I know I can. Now try and do the same with Deron Williams. Well, how’d you do?

Rajon Rondo is the most unorthodox point guard in the league, and his style of play never ceases to amaze. For years people spoke about the ‘Big 3’ and rightly so, but it was Rondo who made them tick with his unrivalled passing ability. Add a title to his resume, even though he was drafted into a good situation, and he has to go above Williams.

So as of right now Williams sits at fourth best point guard in the league, and this is where the argument gets a little tricky. Russell Westbrook is not everybody’s cup of tea, and I get that. He is an erratic shooter and there are facets of his game which need work. But he is only 23 years old, and already has more playoff experience than Williams, including that all important trip to the Finals last year. He has also shown he has that big game mentality. Now Williams was part of some very good Utah Jazz teams, with one of the best coaches the NBA has ever had in Jerry Sloan, yet he never reached the Finals there. Of course some great teams stood in their way back then, most notably the San Antonin Spurs who beat them four games to one in the Western Conference Finals in 2007. So now Williams sits at fifth. (Kind of.)

Things really do become hazy now. Steve Nash, despite being ancient, has more individual honours than Deron, as well as now playing for a title contender in the Lakers, so does that make him the better player? The better choice to have at point guard for your team? He certainly knows how to run an offense in a way no other player does. He has also been a league MVP twice, while Williams has never even made the All-NBA first team. Or maybe you go with the massive potential and upswing of Kyrie Irving at this point? A little premature sure, but in his one season in the league he has already turned heads and made the worst team of 2010, the Cleveland Cavaliers, look respectable once more. If Kyrie was in Deron’s position, think of how good he could make the Brooklyn Nets in the long run. Some may argue this Nets team isn’t built for the long run, but who wouldn’t want long term stability and definite All-Star ability at the point guard position for at least a decade? Similarly, if Williams played for the Cavaliers, would they be a better team? Probably yes, although Williams didn’t exactly set the basketball world ablaze while playing for a poor New Jersey Nets team. So there is competition even for that number five spot I have so cruelly bestowed upon him.

Deron Williams could prove me wrong next year, and I hope he does. Now really is his chance. On paper, this is the best team he will ever have run the point on. Perhaps not as deep as the Utah teams he once graced, but certainly with far more star-power. By next summer he could be hoisting the Larry O’Brien trophy high into the air, whilst also clutching his first NBA Finals MVP award. That would certainly shut me up, but I just can’t see the Barclays Center hanging a banner from the rafters quite yet.

I’m not an NBA player. Not even close. In fact, the player I would resemble the most is one Muggsy Bogues. And even I’m a little bit taller than the 5 foot 3 inches that he was. So far be it from me to criticise an NBA player. An NBA superstar no less. But yet I feel I have to as I can hold it in no longer, so here it goes. Is Deron Williams really that good?

Take a breath before you search for my contact details and give me a mouthful, and hear me out. I like Deron Williams, and I really admire his play. Williams is good, great even, and people talk about him as one of the best point guards in the league, if not the best. But for me, I don’t think he’s a top 5 point guard in the NBA, and I’ll tell you why. Firstly, I believe that both Chris Paul and a healthy Derrick Rose are better players, no question. They influence the game more, and more importantly they make those around them better. I’m not saying Williams doesn’t do these things, just the other two do it better. When you think of Chris Paul and Derrick Rose, you think of that unbelievable desire to win that they both possess. Close your eyes and imagine both Paul and Rose winning and NBA title. Can you do it? I know I can. Now try and do the same with Deron Williams. Well, how’d you do?

Rajon Rondo is the most unorthodox point guard in the league, and his style of play never ceases to amaze. For years people spoke about the ‘Big 3’ and rightly so, but it was Rondo who made them tick with his unrivalled passing ability. Add a title to his resume, even though he was drafted into a good situation, and he has to go above Williams.

So as of right now Williams sits at fourth best point guard in the league, and this is where the argument gets a little tricky. Russell Westbrook is not everybody’s cup of tea, and I get that. He is an erratic shooter and there are facets of his game which need work. But he is only 23 years old, and already has more playoff experience than Williams, including that all important trip to the Finals last year. He has also shown he has that big game mentality. Now Williams was part of some very good Utah Jazz teams, with one of the best coaches the NBA has ever had in Jerry Sloan, yet he never reached the Finals there. Of course some great teams stood in their way back then, most notably the San Antonin Spurs who beat them four games to one in the Western Conference Finals in 2007. So now Williams sits at fifth. (Kind of.)

Things really do become hazy now. Steve Nash, despite being ancient, has more individual honours than Deron, as well as now playing for a title contender in the Lakers, so does that make him the better player? The better choice to have at point guard for your team? He certainly knows how to run an offense in a way no other player does. He has also been a league MVP twice, while Williams has never even made the All-NBA first team. Or maybe you go with the massive potential and upswing of Kyrie Irving at this point? A little premature sure, but in his one season in the league he has already turned heads and made the worst team of 2010, the Cleveland Cavaliers, look respectable once more. If Kyrie was in Deron’s position, think of how good he could make the Brooklyn Nets in the long run. Some may argue this Nets team isn’t built for the long run, but who wouldn’t want long term stability and definite All-Star ability at the point guard position for at least a decade? Similarly, if Williams played for the Cavaliers, would they be a better team? Probably yes, although Williams didn’t exactly set the basketball world ablaze while playing for a poor New Jersey Nets team. So there is competition even for that number five spot I have so cruelly bestowed upon him.

Deron Williams could prove me wrong next year, and I hope he does. Now really is his chance. On paper, this is the best team he will ever have run the point on. Perhaps not as deep as the Utah teams he once graced, but certainly with far more star-power. By next summer he could be hoisting the Larry O’Brien trophy high into the air, whilst also clutching his first NBA Finals MVP award. That would certainly shut me up, but I just can’t see the Barclays Center hanging a banner from the rafters quite yet.

 
Advertisements

Tony Parker: Room For One More?

 

A few days ago I did a piece on Deron Williams in which I broke down his game and compared him to the other elite point guards in the league. Within a couple of hours of this post being completed and going up on the site, a number of people had gotten in contact with me to ask why Tony Parker had mysteriously been left off of the list. Firstly, I thank those people for taking the time to read my work and get back to me, I really appreciate it. Secondly, I just plain forgot. As bad as an excuse as it is, I genuinely accidentally overlooked him, and that’s all there is too it. What’s most ironic about this is the fact that I believe Parker has just come off his most complete season ever in the NBA. So with man running the point for the Spurs now in the mix, it is worth revisiting that list.

To begin, I still believe Chris Paul and a healthy Derrick Rose are better point guards than Parker for the reasons I stated before. They influence their teams on a greater scale, and have a fantastic blend of offensive and defensive maneuverers at their disposal. They bring that balanced play on a nightly basis. Not that Parker doesn’t, he is a fantastic player, and in actual fact is probably the Spurs most important player now too. Tim Duncan is 36, and is beginning to wind down. The Spurs have also used Duncan wisely over the last two years and cut his minutes so as to keep him fresh for the playoffs. So Parker has taken over that leader’s role during the regular season, and he certainly showed it this season. A serious contender for the regular season MVP, the 30 year old eleven year veteran averaged 20 points a game and 6 assists during the postseason too. When you consider that Manu Ginobili shoulders a lot of the scoring burden, as well as Stephen Jackson, not to mention plays being called for Duncan and others like Boris Diaw and Kwahi Leonard quite often, this makes these figures all the more impressive. Both Paul and Rose are younger as well, and have more time to get even better, although Parker is hardly over the hill himself yet.

A Parker versus Rajon Rondo matchup for the number three spots shapes up nicely at this point. On one side you have the flash of Rondo, that ability to scythe through a defence with one pass. Not the greatest shooter out there, but with an unrivalled gift for visioning passing lanes before they have even appeared yet. He makes those around him better, and really what more can you ask of your point guard? He is also gritty as well, who can forget that nasty elbow injury he sustained against Miami in the 2010 playoffs when his arm practically bent in the opposite direction, and then to come back and play, that same game. Huge confidence-boost to his team mates. The other side sees the industrious Parker, not the most extravagant passer of the ball, but you better believe he’ll get the ball where it needs to be. He’s also a far better shooter than Rondo will probably ever be, making him more than just a capable distributor. Spurs coach Greg Popovich expects hard play from all of his players, be they stars or not, and so we can say Parker has that tough streak in him as well. Parker has also won more titles than Rondo, but both have that big game mentality, always raising their game when the stakes are highest.

For me personally I’m going with Rondo at the three spot and Parker at four, followed by Russell Westbrook at number five. Rondo just adds that excitement factor and his vision brings every player into the game to make big plays. Westbrook will also probably jump up this list as time goes by, his potential really knows no bounds. Deron Williams probably does slot in at number six, although Steve Nash and Kyrie Irving will push him hard this coming season.

I may have forgotten Parker, but now that he is back in the fold you can have your say, where do you think Tony Parker fits in this list? Leave your comments below and maybe over the course of the next year the play of Parker will make sure that we never forget about him again.

 

Follow Me ( @NBAEire or @LucaLockheart)